From: billy@anon.com
"Jon Ribbens" wrote in message
news:slrn108htfm.78h.jon+usenet@raven.unequivocal.eu...
> On 2025-07-29, kat wrote:
>> On 28/07/2025 20:04, Mark Goodge wrote:
>>> On Mon, 28 Jul 2025 14:17:20 +0100, JNugent wrote:
>>>> When anyone says "I was taught X at school", they mean, and are taken to
>>>> mean, that it was formally taught to them as part of the purposes and
>>>> objectives of the school.
>>>
>>> No, they don't. They really don't. You appear to be in a minority of
>>> one as regards this particular non-standard opinion.
>>
>> I would say that I was "taught" what I needed to know to pass exams,
>> but that there were other things I "learned". I was taught how to
>> play hockey, but I learned I was useless at it.
>>
>> Yes, it is all education, but I tend to see a difference. I didn't
>> have to agree with opinions of teachers.
>
> Ok, but that's not what Mark and JNugent are talking about. You are
> making a distinction between information deliberately passed on by
> teachers and things you learned for yourself. JNugent is purporting
> to make a distinction between different types of information passed
> on by teachers, and he's clearly wrong, and your comment doesn't
> support what he's saying.
I've relayed this anecdote before; but it bears repetition in this
context.
I went to a rugby playing school. The school took on a new teacher who
both taught Geography, ISTR, and doubled up as the Assistant Games
Master.
This chap was either a Kiwi or a Polynesian/Fijian/Samoan whatever;
and was always immaculately turned out, as if he was straight out of
the barbers; sometimes in a blazer with a badge on it. Rumour had it
that he was full Rugby international.
But there was no Internet in those days, and most of us were more
interested in the doings of Jimmy Greaves at Chelsea,
Anyway one day, in class, during a lesson somebody asked about, or
just happened to mention Australian Aborigines. And this chap just
exploded "The Aborigines are no better than animals. They eat
insects and all sorts etc. etc. ". This was met by stunned silence
from all of us; as this chap had never lost his cool before.
We all assumed I think, that this description of the Australian
Aborigines as being no better than animals, wasn't part of the
Official School Curriculum.
And was probably the worst example of overt racism that any of
us had ever encountered up until that point. Although I doubt any
of the 25 - 30 of us reported it.
While as to anti-semitism; it wasn't until years later, that
I first encounted people who were apparently obsessed with
discovering whether people in the public eye or even colleagues
were "actually Jewish" or not.
bb
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|