Just a sample of the Echomail archive
Cooperative anarchy at its finest, still active today. Darkrealms is the Zone 1 Hub.
|    ENGLISH_TUTOR    |    English Tutoring for Students of the Eng    |    4,347 messages    |
[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]
|    Message 2,433 of 4,347    |
|    Alexander Koryagin to Ardith Hinton    |
|    Name    |
|    29 Jan 19 20:38:40    |
      Hi, Ardith Hinton!       I read your message from 29.01.2019 00:24                      AK>> For instance, a teacher asks this question of an unknown boy in        AK>> the school. Should he ask "what is your second name?"               AH> Speaking as a teacher: Unless the school was very small I'd need to        AH> know more than the first name to distinguish one kid from        AH> another... especially if their parents chose it during a spate of        AH> increasing trendiness. When one of my former students rushes up to        AH> me enthusiastically & says "Hi... I'm Cathy (or Debbie, or whatever        AH> name +/- half my female students had back then)... remember me??" I        AH> must confess I probably won't unless they give me a few more clues.        AH> As a teacher & as a parent I also understand that the school has to        AH> use a person's legal name on all official records, and there is a        AH> lot of paperwork involved in establishing that everybody is who        AH> they say they are. If Molly's legal name is Molly Moon the school        AH> has no authority to change it without documentation which her new        AH> parents can't supply unless they've formally adopted her. But I        AH> gather Molly is new to this school & hasn't voiced her concerns to        AH> the staff.              That girl had authority - she could hypnotize all the world ;-). In that       example "name" was used as a full name. Although, the author could easily use       "surname" etc.               AH> Depending on the age of your unknown boy, I would be inclined to        AH> say "family name" or "surname" rather than "second name".              What about "last name"? Is it better than "second name"?               AH> Around these parts it is more common than not for people to have        AH> two or more given names... and I'm told they may not appear in the        AH> order we're used to, relative to the family name, if the individual        AH> in question has just arrived from China or SomePlace Else & does        AH> not as yet know how to translate their given name into something        AH> which those of us who don't speak their lingo will remember &/or        AH> think we understand. There's another possible complication too, if        AH> the teacher doesn't know a boy's previous history. I can't say for        AH> sure whether you'd automatically identify yourself as "Koryagin"        AH> nowadays, if you'd spent the last umpteen years in a British        AH> private school, because I don't move in those circles. But I see        AH> plenty of evidence in the works of various authors that the        AH> tradition lasted for a long time....              Let's take, for the instance, an excerpt from my old translation -- we see a       boyscout council with a strict head teacher sitting at the head of the table.              -----Beginning of the citation-----       ....       There was no time to hesitate. Slavka quickly stood up.        "I am against!"        Of course everybody turned around, and Elisaveta Dmitrievna said       discontentedly:        "It seems to me that you aren't a council member, and, as far as I know, you       are a newcomer!"        "You are not a council member either," said Slavka calmly.        "Ah, what an impudence! What's your last name?"        "I am Semibratov," said Slavka       ----- The end of the citation -----              So, could she ask him "what's your name?"              Bye, Ardith!       Alexander Koryagin       english_tutor 2019              ---        * Origin: ** nntps://fidonews.mine.nu ** Finland ** (2:221/6.0)    |
[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]
(c) 1994, bbs@darkrealms.ca