XPost: alt.conspiracy, ba.general, la.general 
 XPost: soc.culture.jewish 
 From: dorfman@rahul.net 
  
 The Revd Terence Fformby-Smythe (reniggade@anglicam.org) wrote: 
 : On Sun, 29 Jun 2003 20:45:52 +0000 (UTC), Merlin Dorfman 
 :  wrote: 
  
 ... 
  
 : > 
 : >: So are you or aren't you? 
 : > 
 : >     Are I or aren't I what? 
  
 : Are you or are you not conceding that the predominance of jews in 
 : fraud and insider trading is due to New York being jew Central? 
  
      Since I don't concede the predominance of Jews in fraud and 
 insider trading, the second half of the syllogism is nonsense.  As 
 is, of course, the first half.  You made the accusation but have 
 been unable to prove it (because it's untrue); you have never done 
 more than cite specific instances without even attempting to show 
 that it constitutes "predominance."  (You can't, because it doesn't.) 
  
 ... 
  
 : >: >: I was never on a "hook".  You can't libel a whole race.  Not even 
 : >: >: jews. 
  
     So lies directed against Jews do not constitute libel? 
  
 : >: >     Have you ever heard the term "Blood Libel?"  It's directed 
 : >: >against an entire (by your definition) race. 
 : > 
 : >: It's a jew term.  It means nothing to the rest of the world. 
 : > 
 : >     Blood libel is directed against Jews, if that's what you mean. 
  
 : It's the jews' own term. 
  
      For a lie directed against Jews. 
  
 ... 
  
 : >     I can see it now: 
 : >     " 'Rev' claims all Jews are liars and criminals.  I am not 
 : >either, so I seek a remedy." 
 : >     " I concede that you are not a liar or a criminal.  You are a 
 : >mutant." 
 : >     "Er...ah...OK, thanks, I think." 
 : >     This may be the first time in  history that the vast majority 
 : >are called "mutants" and the small minority are considered to be 
 : >"normal." 
  
 : That's because you've misunderstood.  The vast majority are criminals. 
 : The small mutant minority are not. 
  
      I've understood your claim perfectly.  I also understand that it's 
 incorrect.  The only question is whether it is libelous under the law 
 (and which country's law). 
  
 --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)