home  bbs  files  messages ]

      ZZLI4422             linux.debian.devel             1179 messages      

[ previous | next | reply ]

[ list messages | list forums ]

  Msg # 1161 of 1179 on ZZLI4422, Thursday 11-05-25, 4:10  
  From: DAVID KALNISCHKIES  
  To: ALL  
  Subj: Re: apt-ftparchive alternatives (was: Ha  
 15:01:18 
 1, 
 autolearn_force= 
 protocol="application/pgp- 
  On 2025-11-03 13:22:28 +0100 (+0100), David Kalnischkies wrote: 
 > > apt-ftparchive, an aging tool, which as far as I know sees its only 
 > > serious usage by your employer in the form of Launchpad, right? 
 > 
 > A quick sidebar: what more modern alternatives do folks recommend? For 
 years 
 > (decades?) I've used apt-ftparchive release, followed by gpg --clear-sign 
 of 
 > InRelease, for a quick command-line solution to create small personal 
 > secure-APT compatible Debian package repositories. Is there something else 
 > similarly simple these days? 
  
 fwiw I wasn't saying that people have to stop using, nor that it will 
 disappear any time soon. It is too useful for src:apt for testing – 
 and just like src:apt also includes an HTTP server that I constantly 
 use in place of `python -m http.server`, it's not particular hard to 
 keep `apt-ftparchive` around for personal use. Just don't expect that 
 any development that is not directly motivated by testing/personal 
 usage will happen or that it will get somehow "user-friendly". 
  
  
 But apt-ftparchive has the option to use BDB (= Berkeley DB) for caching 
 and while I still believe it wouldn't be too hard to change to another 
 DB (minus the probably hard part of vacillating a transition), I don't 
 see it happen any time soon. At least I don't see why I should do it & 
 so did nobody else in the last 12 years [0]  (also: #1119193). 
  
  
 That said, by all means, feel free to seek and use alternatives. 
 I am not able to offer any advice through. 
 Just trying to clarify the status of it, as I see it, 
 to avoid misunderstandings. 
  
  
 Best regards 
  
 David Kalnischkies 
  
 [0] https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2013/07/msg00132.html 
  
 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- 
  
 iQIzBAABCgAdFiEE5sn+Q4uCja/tn0GrMRvlz3HQeIMFAmkLZp8ACgkQMRvlz3HQ 
 eIM9bxAAjSEh5r4gvSFqk2qrPwf+Gu0Bi4AHOq2PKm5GVdo0hAzOcrK4V7oTcQIi 
 jEAdCV1g8+fph7bsmcTtCFMyl2KWrHZr4rw8aKUPmEHcZ20Z7htB0PJFTy50zEOd 
 d4YRNLUnumbjJET9jBaGN5Ya1Ge4dzaDblUJaYpVmpD84lrkTQIVaMA/XRkvHpUV 
 UHtSh+Fx0Hxa1S9n7uPO/MaiQfhQFp3R6sNwi+WRdYjQYLusu+OhhLLSqfrgWz8N 
 1Fq0YNQibhgJTHUGRYPLQboYbx0F3t7Nvb9vkMx6soKlMBHCNGxDvQYweC/PYPY4 
 niXDmFghrRdwETWGhUFHwswKqMpTWG7qi7E/2jDEldNlOkkLFvIh/XKqqh6ZR3Zr 
 CR8pjA4ECREJx8bnBH6qyxSo8VHt7HOC6sESe8NRw+uESZNlGrI2QWf2p+gBaI/H 
 3zO7S9wpcMdy8tNDKgQdrTFU1hjTtME8Ib3vnTVxrHtJFBqYzBaxNrA3xuRZd4Hg 
 rKY8/45K9lJGhi9sHTIuQKJQLCAIRY67nIQ9gZl+GaK8A51eCokGknaMC/GdNfyp 
 VG8g7+KKSN8M/kUbjRK8JORGV4RjzLJBi4w5TU5cJEZje/KqfDioMwVPIukmQEnj 
 uzzjhG++jc4IvM4RUyx9ZlMSMo98AzgAmp9H0NyORZyzpibulr8= 
 =jQWz 
 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- 
  
 --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2) 
    

[ list messages | list forums | previous | next | reply ]

search for:

328,082 visits
(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca