From: roehling@debian.org
Hi,
* Russ Allbery [2025-08-14 11:07]:
>Otto Keklinen writes:
>
>> I have now witnessed several cases where a maintainer blatantly
>> ignored the MRs their package received.
>
>As several of us have been noting for some time now, it is very easy to
>accidentally ignore Salsa MRs because the defaults don't send email to the
>maintainer when an MR is opened. I realize that this may look like
>"blatantly ignoring" an MR to people who regularly use Salsa, but for
>maintainers who do not, it's often entirely accidental.
>
>Also, speaking as someone who works on Debian and other free software
>projects in bursts, sometimes I just forget about things even if I saw
>them. I try to use checklists and work through any open issues
>systematically before uploading, and I still cannot count the number of
>times that I have uploaded a package with open bugs because I forgot to
>check the BTS before uploading because I was thinking about something
>else. I will doubtless do the same thing with Salsa MRs as well.
>
>It's not personal! And people taking it personally or thinking that it's
>some sort of political statement or intentional snub are reading hostile
>emotions into something that's simply due to being human.
>
Very much this!
This has happened to me in the past despite using DDPO and tracker.d.o
regularly. Yes, DDPO shows open MRs, but it is incredibily easy to miss,
especially if you happen to be involved in more than a handful of
packages.
In fact, I literally did "Ctrl+F !1" on my DDPO page on a hunch just
now, and stumbled upon a pytest MR which has been sitting in Salsa for
over a month and has become obsolete two days ago.
I've seen someone suggest elsewhere in this thread to add an Action Item
to tracker.d.o, and I agree this would very much improve MR visibility.
Still, I'm going to mess up at times (I have "ignored" Multi-Arch hints
more than once already).
Cheers
Timo
--
Timo Rhlin
9B03 EBB9 8300 DF97 C2B1 23BF CC8C 6BDD 1403
F4CA
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----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=TC1D
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|