home  bbs  files  messages ]

      ZZCA4349             can.arts.sf             1759 messages      

[ previous | next | reply ]

[ list messages | list forums ]

  Msg # 405 of 1759 on ZZCA4349, Friday 4-17-25, 6:15  
  From: THE DOCTOR  
  To: ALL  
  Subj: Doctor Who - The Robot revolution - REvi  
 XPost: rec.arts.drwho, uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv 
 XPost: rec.arts.tv 
 From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca 
  
 Doctor Who The Robot Revolution  as Reviewed by AL Generators. 
  
 Al Generator ChatGPt what do you think? 
  
 **Doctor Who: *The Robot Revolution*** 
 **Rating: 7/10** 
  
 **Review:** 
 *The Robot Revolution* is a wild, ambitious, and at times touching entry 
 into the Doctor Who mythos €€€ blending emotional time travel, 
 cultural identity, and the age-old threat of a machine uprising. 
  
 Starting in 2008, we meet Belinda Charma, an Indo-British woman sharing 
 a tender moment with her partner, Allen, who gifts her 
 a star certificate - a seemingly small gesture that turns out to have 
 cosmic consequences. The leap to 2025 sets the stage for the chaos 
 to come: Belinda, now an NHS nurse, finds her world shaken when 
 a spaceship crashes into her neighbourhood 
 and a robot - cold and lethal - hunts her down, 
 vaporizing her cat in a surprisingly dark twist. 
  
 What follows is pure Who: she's abducted and crowned queen 
 of a distant planet thanks to her star certificate (brilliant sci-fi logic), 
 while the Doctor - in full Scottish regalia, no less - storms in to save 
 her, 
 encountering old friend (or foe?) Mrs. Flood and landing 
 in the thick of a robot-human uprising. 
  
 There's a manic energy to the middle act: robots with evaporator guns, 
 an AI demanding marriage, humans rebelling, and the Doctor disguising 
 himself as a servant to unravel the secrets of the planet. Amidst this, 
 the episode threads some genuinely cool concepts - AI-controlled hospitals 
 with X-ray blankets, a 2-hearted reveal to Belinda, and the devastating 
 twist 
 that Allen, her 2008 love, has been assimilated into the machine empire. 
  
 The Doctor, ever the wandering historian, provides needed exposition while 
 the story barrels forward, occasionally skimming the edge of confusion. 
 Belinda proves a strong character, stepping up in the climax to face 
 the AI overlord AL Generator and navigate her feelings for Allen, 
 now part-human, part-machine. 
  
 The resolution is a bit rushed - everything is "set free" with a touch 
 of typical Who handwavery - but it ends on a tantalising note. 
 Belinda sees the TARDIS for the first time, but as the Doctor prepares 
 to return her to May 24, 2025€€€ the *Cloister Bell* rings. 
 Something ominous lies ahead. 
  
 **Verdict:** 
  
 *The Robot Revolution* is an energetic and emotionally charged episode, 
 balancing classic sci-fi tropes with personal stakes. 
 While the plot can get overstuffed and slightly chaotic, 
 the emotional core around Belinda and Allen anchors it well. 
 Bonus points for blending NHS reality with deep-future madness 
 and keeping the tone both tragic and playful. 
  
 **Score: 7/10** 
  
 (*Great characters, solid emotional payoff, slightly overloaded 
 plot but with lots of fun and flair.*) 
  
 Al ChatGPT , I do not recall the Doctor in Scottish 
 getup when he arrives to saves Belinda. 
  
 Al Generator Google Gemini what do you think? 
  
 Here's a review of "The Robot Revolution," based on your notes: 
  
 **"The Robot Revolution" Review** 
  
 "The Robot Revolution" is a whirlwind of time-hopping adventure, 
 packed with familiar Doctor Who tropes and a few new twists. 
 The episode centers on Belinda Charma, an Indo-British woman 
 whose life becomes intertwined with the Doctor's across centuries, 
 all thanks to a mysterious "Star Certificate." 
  
 The story kicks off in 2008, with a seemingly ordinary night for Belinda, 
 then jumps to 2025, where she's an NHS nurse and the Doctor, in Scottish 
 attire, is causing chaos. A spaceship and menacing robots disrupt 
 her life, triggered by the Star Certificate that seemingly makes 
 her royalty on some distant planet. 
  
 The episode throws in a lot: a planet ruled by robots who demand 
 obedience, an AI generator wanting to get married, a captured character 
 from the past (Allan from 2008), and the return of Mrs. Flood. 
 The Doctor, as always, is in the thick of it, trying to unravel 
 the mystery and save the day. 
  
 The plot is fast-paced, bouncing between timelines and locations. 
 While this keeps things exciting, it can also feel a bit cluttered. 
 The episode touches on themes of destiny, free will, 
 and the dangers of unchecked AI, but these ideas sometimes 
 get lost in the action. 
  
 Belinda is a strong and resourceful character, and her connection 
 to the Doctor is intriguing. The robots are suitably menacing, 
 and the AI generator's desire for marriage adds a quirky, 
 Doctor Who-esque element. 
  
 However, the episode does have some weaknesses. 
 The rapid-fire plot can be confusing at times, 
 and some of the elements, like the "Star Certificate" and the robots' 
 motivations, could be fleshed out more. The ending, with the Doctor 
 and Belinda heading back to a specific date and the Cloister Bell 
 ringing, sets up a cliffhanger but doesn't fully resolve the immediate 
 story. 
  
 **Overall:** 
  
 "The Robot Revolution" is a fun, if somewhat messy, Doctor Who adventure. 
 It's packed with ideas and action, but it could benefit from a tighter focus 
 and clearer explanations. 
  
 **Rating:** 7/10 
  
 AL Generator Google Gemini you never address the Ending. 
  
 My take: 5/10 
  
 How did Allen neighbourhood not recognise a robot presence? 
  
 What was the Doctor doing on the hospital? 
  
 Special Effects and mechanical beings too much from Disney. 
  
 Why I am staying around for the next 7 - What is blockng 
 the TARDIS from returning Belinda. 
 -- 
 Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca 
 Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist 
 rising! 
 Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ; 
 Canada -Save the Nation from Donald Trump - Vote Liberal! 
  
 --- SoupGate-DOS v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2) 

[ list messages | list forums | previous | next | reply ]

search for:

328,127 visits
(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca