home  bbs  files  messages ]

      ZZCA4349             can.arts.sf             1759 messages      

[ previous | next | reply ]

[ list messages | list forums ]

  Msg # 182 of 1759 on ZZCA4349, Wednesday 9-17-24, 5:08  
  From: THE DOCTOR  
  To: ALL  
  Subj: ChatGPT reviews Doctor Who - Army of Gho  
 XPost: uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv 
 XPost: rec.arts.sf.fandom, rec.arts.tv 
 From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca 
  
 Here€€€s a review of *Doctor Who: Army of Ghosts*: 
  
 --- 
  
 *Army of Ghosts*, the first part of the series two finale, 
 marks the beginning of a high-stakes, emotionally charged 
 story arc that brings the Doctor, Rose, and humanity 
 face-to-face with one of their deadliest foes. 
 It sets the stage for the epic conclusion while blending 
 science fiction, suspense, and heartbreak. 
  
 The episode opens with an ominous monologue from Rose, 
 foreshadowing her impending separation from the Doctor. 
 This immediately establishes a somber tone and prepares 
 the audience for an emotionally heavy finale. The Doctor 
 and Rose return to contemporary Earth, where they discover 
 that ghost-like apparitions have been appearing all over 
 the world. While many people have accepted these "ghosts" 
 as a normal part of life, the Doctor is skeptical and sets 
 out to investigate. 
  
 The domestic scenes with Jackie Tyler add a grounded, 
 human element to the episode. Jackie's humorous belief 
 that one of the ghosts is her deceased husband, Pete, 
 gives a poignant insight into how these apparitions have 
 impacted ordinary lives. Her dynamic with the Doctor is 
 as lively as ever, providing moments of levity in 
 an otherwise tense episode. 
  
 The Doctor soon discovers that the ghosts are the result 
 of a breach in the fabric of reality, caused by the 
 activities of Torchwood, a secretive organization dedicated 
 to investigating alien technology. The reveal of Torchwood 
 and its high-tech headquarters in Canary Wharf is an exciting 
 moment for longtime fans, as it ties together threads that 
 have been building throughout the series. Torchwood's 
 moral ambiguity is well-presented, with their leader, 
 Yvonne Hartman, coming across as both pragmatic and ruthless. 
 She's driven by a desire to protect humanity but 
 at the cost of manipulating dangerous alien technology. 
  
 The episode's pacing is strong, with a gradual build-up 
 of suspense as the Doctor and Torchwood clash over how 
 to handle the situation. The ghosts are soon revealed 
 to be Cybermen from a parallel universe, using the breach 
 to invade Earth. This reveal is well-executed, especially 
 for fans who have been following the arc of the Cybermen 
 throughout the series. The Cybermen, as always, 
 are a terrifying threat, with their cold logic 
 and emotionless demeanor adding to the growing sense of dread. 
  
 But *Army of Ghosts* doesn't stop there. In one of 
 the series' most thrilling twists, the episode reveals 
 that another threat is lurking within the breach: the Daleks. 
 The sudden appearance of the Daleks and the reveal 
 of the "Genesis Ark" raises the stakes to an entirely new level. 
 The idea of two of the Doctor's greatest enemies clashing 
 in a battle for Earth sets up an exciting premise 
 for the following episode. The tension between 
 the Cybermen and Daleks is immediately palpable, 
 and the audience is left on the edge of their seats, 
 wondering how the Doctor and Rose can possibly survive 
 such a formidable conflict. 
  
 Rose€€€s role in this episode is significant, as it sets up 
 her eventual fate. Her bravery and loyalty to the Doctor 
 are evident throughout, particularly in her determination 
 to stay by his side despite the growing danger. There's 
 a deep sense of foreboding in her interactions with him, 
 as the earlier monologue about their impending separation 
 hangs over every scene. The chemistry between the Doctor 
 and Rose continues to shine, and their relationship remains 
 a central emotional anchor for the story. 
  
 The Doctor's dynamic with Torchwood is another highlight 
 of the episode. He's immediately distrustful of their 
 methods and their willingness to manipulate alien technology 
 for their own ends. His moral compass clashes with Yvonne's 
 pragmatic approach, creating tension between them. 
 The Doctor's righteous anger at their reckless use 
 of the breach reflects his deep sense of responsibility 
 for protecting the universe, even from those who believe 
 they're doing the right thing. 
  
 Visually, *Army of Ghosts* is impressive. The scenes 
 of ghosts appearing around the world are eerie and 
 well-executed, and the Torchwood headquarters feels 
 both sleek and ominous, reflecting the organisation's 
 secretive and morally complex nature. The design 
 of the Cybermen continues to impress, with their metallic, 
 imposing presence creating an ever-present sense of danger. 
 The Daleks' entrance is suitably dramatic, reinforcing 
 their status as one of the most fearsome creatures 
 in the *Doctor Who* universe. 
  
 While the episode is packed with action and suspense, 
 it also takes time to explore deeper themes. The use 
 of the ghosts as a metaphor for loss and the human 
 desire to reconnect with the past is a subtle 
 but powerful undercurrent. Jackie's belief that 
 one of the ghosts could be Pete is a poignant reminder 
 of the pain of grief and how people can cling to even 
 the faintest hope of being reunited with loved ones. 
 This theme of loss is echoed in Rose's impending 
 separation from the Doctor, adding an emotional depth to the narrative. 
  
 The cliffhanger ending of *Army of Ghosts* is one of the most 
 memorable in *Doctor Who* history. The tension between 
 the Cybermen and Daleks, the Doctor's helplessness 
 in the face of such overwhelming odds, and the uncertainty 
 of Rose's fate create an unforgettable climax that leaves 
 the audience eagerly anticipating the next episode. 
 The build-up to this moment is expertly paced, with 
 each revelation adding to the growing sense of dread and inevitability. 
  
 In conclusion, *Army of Ghosts* is an exceptional penultimate episode, 
 combining thrilling action, emotional weight, and high-stakes drama. 
 It successfully sets up the series finale while delivering 
 some of the most iconic moments in *Doctor Who*. The 
 combination of Cybermen, Daleks, and the Doctor's emotional 
 journey makes for a gripping and unforgettable story. 
  
 --- 
  
 Rating: 9/10 
  
 With strong performances, a thrilling plot, and emotional depth, 
 *Army of Ghosts* is a standout episode that perfectly sets 
 the stage for the epic finale to follow. 
 The cliffhanger and the high-stakes conflict between 
 the Doctor's greatest enemies make this an unforgettable part of the series. 
 -- 
 Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca 
 Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist 
 rising! 
 Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ; 
  
 --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2) 

[ list messages | list forums | previous | next | reply ]

search for:

328,128 visits
(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca