home  bbs  files  messages ]

      ZZCA4349             can.arts.sf             1759 messages      

[ previous | next | reply ]

[ list messages | list forums ]

  Msg # 1668 of 1759 on ZZCA4349, Monday 7-14-24, 8:13  
  From: THE DOCTOR  
  To: THE DOCTOR  
  Subj: Re: Doctor Who Empire of Death - Review   
 XPost: rec.arts.drwho, uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv 
 XPost: rec.arts.sf.fandom, rec.arts.tv 
 From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca 
  
 In article , 
 The Doctor  wrote: 
 >ChatGPT 
 > 
 >TV Review: "Doctor Who: The Empire of Death" 
 > 
 >In a bold return to classic Doctor Who themes, Russell T Davies crafts an 
 >ambitious narrative in "The Empire of Death" that pits the Doctor against 
 >the formidable Sutekh once more. This episode dives headfirst into nostalgia 
 >while pushing the boundaries of the show's mythos, resulting in a mixed 
 >bag of classic charm and contemporary ambition. 
 > 
 >Davies wastes no time plunging viewers into the action with Susan's 
 >ominous ability to "breathe out death," setting a chilling tone 
 >that persists throughout. The stakes escalate swiftly as UNIT's arsenal 
 >is aimed at Sutekh, portrayed with chilling malevolence by an unseen force 
 >known as the "Harbinger." The race against time, quite literally, as Mel 
 >and the Doctor combat a dust cloud threatening Earth, 
 >adds urgency and dynamism to the plot. 
 > 
 >Central to the episode's intrigue is the enigmatic Ruby and her ties to both 
 >the Doctor and Sutekh's universe. Actress Melanie Gibson delivers a standout 
 >performance, infusing Ruby with a mix of vulnerability and determination. 
 >Her journey to reunite with her real mother amidst the chaos amplifies 
 >the emotional core of the narrative. 
 > 
 >However, the episode's strength lies in its exploration of Sutekh's return 
 > and his eerie resonance as a villain. Taunting the Doctor with his past 
 defeats 
 > and manipulating the fabric of time and death, Sutekh emerges as a 
 formidable 
 > foe, challenging the Doctor's ingenuity and resolve. The revelation that 
 Sutekh 
 > has become part of the TARDIS elevates the stakes to cosmic proportions, 
 > cleverly tying past encounters with current events. 
 > 
 >Visually, "The Empire of Death" excels in creating a bleak, desolate 
 >atmosphere  reflective of Sutekh's influence. From the frozen wastelands of 
 >Sutekh's  universe to the claustrophobic Time Chamber, each setting is 
 >meticulously crafted to enhance the story's tension and drama. 
 >The incorporation of practical effects and CGI blends seamlessly, 
 >enriching the viewing experience without overshadowing the narrative. 
 > 
 >Despite its strengths, the episode occasionally falters under the weight 
 >of its own ambition. The resolution, involving Ruby's manipulation of TARDIS 
 >technology, feels rushed and overly convenient, detracting from the 
 otherwise 
 >gripping climax. Additionally, some character arcs, particularly Mel's 
 >entanglement with Sutekh, feel underdeveloped amidst the broader narrative 
 >scope. 
 > 
 >Ultimately, "The Empire of Death" is a testament to Russell T Davies' 
 ability 
 >to rejuvenate classic Doctor Who elements while infusing them with modern 
 >storytelling sensibilities. It's an episode that resonates with both 
 >long-time fans and newcomers, offering a tantalising glimpse into the show's 
 >enduring legacy and the boundless creativity of its creators. 
 > 
 >Rating: 4/5 stars 
 > 
 >Despite its flaws, "The Empire of Death" stands as a testament 
 >to the enduring appeal of Doctor Who under Davies' stewardship, 
 >promising a thrilling future for the beloved series. 
 > 
 >Google Gemini 
 > 
 >Doctor Who: Susan Breathes Out Death €€€ A Universe-Ending Romp with a Spoon 
 > 
 >Russell T Davies' "Susan Breathes Out Death" throws everything - time 
 travel, 
 >cosmic entities, and a spoon - into a whirlwind finale for this Doctor Who 
 >season.  While the plot is a tad overstuffed, the high stakes and surprising 
 >emotional beats make for a thrilling conclusion. 
 > 
 >The story picks up right where we left off: Sutekh, the ancient evil, 
 >possessing UNIT and threatening to engulf the universe.  The Doctor, 
 >ever resourceful, utilises a UNIT-built time travel model to combat 
 >Sutekh's own TARDIS-like vessel.  The special effects depicting these 
 >clashing time machines are a highlight, showcasing the scale of the threat. 
 > 
 >Ncuti Gatwa's Doctor shines in this episode.  Her determination to fight 
 >for life against all odds is palpable.  However, it's Mel who gets 
 >a surprising arc.  The gradual corruption by Sutekh adds a layer of tragedy 
 >and raises the stakes for the Doctor's mission. 
 > 
 >The episode isn't without flaws.  The pacing can be breakneck at times, 
 >with exposition crammed between universe-ending battles. 
 >The reveal of Ruby's mother feels somewhat rushed, 
 >and the significance of the mysterious neighbour is left hanging for now. 
 > 
 >However, the episode's strengths outweigh its weaknesses.  The Doctor's 
 >resourcefulness, the emotional weight of Mel's fate, and the epic showdown 
 > against Sutekh deliver a satisfying conclusion.  The cliffhanger ending, 
 > with a new threat potentially looming, leaves viewers eager for more. 
 > 
 >Final Verdict: 3.5 out of 5 stars.  "Susan Breathes Out Death" 
 >is a thrilling and emotional conclusion filled with universe-ending 
 >peril and surprising character moments.  While the plot might be a bit 
 >overstuffed, the high stakes and strong performances make for a memorable 
 >finale.  The cliffhanger ending promises even more adventures to come. 
 >This episode might not be a classic, but it brings a satisfying close 
 >to the season with the return of a classic foe 
 >and the introduction of a new mystery. 
  
 Whoops! I  rate it 7/10 
  
 Overall Season 1  5/10 ! 
  
 Bad Wolf season this is not! 
 -- 
 Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca 
 Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist 
 rising! 
 Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ; 
 United Kingdom save the NAtion on 4 July 2024 vote Liberal Democrat 
  
 --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2) 

[ list messages | list forums | previous | next | reply ]

search for:

328,076 visits
(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca