home  bbs  files  messages ]

      ZZCA4349             can.arts.sf             1759 messages      

[ previous | next | reply ]

[ list messages | list forums ]

  Msg # 1495 of 1759 on ZZCA4349, Monday 7-14-24, 8:10  
  From: THE DOCTOR  
  To: ALL  
  Subj: Google Gemini reviews Doctor Who The Ten  
 XPost: rec.arts.drwho, uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv 
 XPost: rec.arts.tv 
 From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca 
  
 Doctor Who: The Tenth Planet - A Pivotal Moment in Doctor Who History 
  
 Based on the information from the provided website 
 [invalid URL the tenth planet doctor who ON Chakoteya. 
 net], here's a review of Doctor Who: The Tenth Planet: 
  
 Story 
  
 "The Tenth Planet"  is  a  historically  significant 
 serial  in  Doctor Who  history.  It  marks  the  First Doctor's 
 regeneration  into  the  Second Doctor, 
 played  by  Patrick Troughton.  The narrative  revolves 
 around  the  discovery  of  Mondas,  Earth's  long-lost 
 twin  planet,  inhabited  by  the  ruthless  Cybermen. 
 The Doctor  must  prevent  the  Cybermen  from  invading 
  Earth  and  draining  its  energy  resources. 
  
 Review (Limited Due to Missing Episode) 
  
     Regeneration Introduction: This serial introduces 
  a foundational concept in Doctor Who: regeneration. 
  Seeing the First Doctor regenerate is a major turning 
  point for long-time fans. 
   
     Introduction of the Cybermen: "The Tenth Planet" properly 
  introduces the Cybermen as iconic enemies of the Doctor. 
  Their ruthless nature and desire to convert humans 
  establishes them as a significant threat. 
   
     High Stakes: With Earth facing invasion by the Cybermen, 
  the stakes are enormously high, adding tension to the narrative. 
  
 Possible Weaknesses (Considering Limited Information): 
  
     Missing Episode: Only three out of the four episodes exist 
  in the BBC archives. This means experiencing the complete 
  narrative is not possible. 
   
     Slow Pacing in Classic Who: Classic Doctor Who sometimes 
  featured a slower narrative pace compared to modern iterations. 
   
     Limited Companion Roles (Based on Summary): The summary doesn't 
  detail much about Steven and Dodo's roles in the narrative. 
  
 Overall Thoughts (Limited Scope) 
  
 "The Tenth Planet"  holds  historical  significance 
 for  introducing  regeneration  and  the  Cybermen 
 as  major  elements  of  Doctor Who.  However, 
 the  missing  episode  creates  a  barrier 
 to  fully  experiencing  the  story. 
  
 Would I Recommend Watching It? 
  
     For Fans of Classic Doctor Who: 6/10 
  (Only recommended if you have access to reconstructions 
  of the lost episode and are comfortable with incomplete stories. 
  The historical significance and introduction of the Cybermen 
  might be worth it for die-hard fans) 
   
     For Fans of Modern Doctor Who: 3/10 (The historical significance 
  might be interesting, but the missing episode, slower pace, 
  and limited companion roles could make it a difficult watch) 
  
 Here are some additional points to consider that might help you decide: 
  
     If you can find reviews based on reconstructions of "The Tenth Planet," 
     those might give you a better idea of the complete story's enjoyability. 
   
     Classic Doctor Who had a different style than the modern series. 
  If you're new to classic Who, consider watching earlier stories 
  featuring the First Doctor to get a feel for the era's aesthetics 
  and storytelling before diving into "The Tenth Planet." 
  
 I hope this helps!  While  "The Tenth Planet"  is  important 
 in  Doctor Who  history,  the  missing  episode  makes 
 it  a  tough  recommendation  for  casual  viewers. 
 -- 
 Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca 
 Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist 
 rising! 
 Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ; 
  
 --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05 
  * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2) 

[ list messages | list forums | previous | next | reply ]

search for:

328,104 visits
(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca